If you are a big proponent of hi-res audio and great audio experience, you are probably aware of surround sound formats and surround sound systems.
Surround sound systems are for their immersive experience and can be found in movie cinemas, some media rooms, and dedicated home theaters.
You will often see numbers such as 5.1, 7.1, 7.1.4, and so on. These numbers represent the number of channels.
- 1- This is a surround sound configuration that comprises 5 dedicated speakers and one subwoofer channel. The speakers include 3 front speakers (left, right, and center) and 2 surround sound speakers (left and right).
- 1- This configuration is made up of 7 dedicated speakers and one subwoofer channel. It is similar to 5.1 but utilizes 2 rear surround speakers (left and right).
- 1.4- This configuration is similar to a 7.1 system but utilizes 4 extra height channels. These channels can use 4 up-firing speakers, 4 ceiling speakers, or 4 height speakers to create a bubble around the listener.
However, these systems are expensive and complicated to set up since they use several speakers that need to be placed correctly and calibrated to best suit your room depending on its layout. This is where surround sound headphones come in.
Surround sound headphones are compact, convenient, and cheaper compared to speaker surround sound systems. This is achieved by use virtualization technologies on stereo headphone sets but can also be done using smaller drivers that are packed inside the headphone cups to reproduce the surround sound effect.
These headphones can be used for watching movies, listening to music but are mostly used by gamers that want an immersive gaming experience and a sense of directionality.
So, how do these headphones work, and are they worth in the long run? These are some of the questions I will help you better understand.
Contents and Quick Navigation
Virtual surround sound headphones
Virtual surround sound headphones utilize 2 stereo drivers that are usually between 40mm and 50mm with one driver for each ear.
These drivers are used to mimic a surround sound setup by using psychoacoustics (how people perceive sound) and Head-Related Transfer Function or HRTF techniques to create spatial sound effects.
These techniques take advantage of how sound waves hit our ears and how these sound waves interact with the environment and parts of our body from the shoulders to the curves in our ears to give a sense of direction and space.
On a basic level, these techniques use level, time, and other subtle sound differences to give you an idea of where the sound comes from.
Information from these interactions is used by researchers to create a set of algorithms that are used on sound processors (processing chips) to add delay, volume adjustments (Levels), and other aural cues to mimic a proper surround sound system.
The chip can be found on an onboard DSP in the headphone or a dongle that comes with the headphones package that can be plugged into your audio source be it a laptop or a gaming console.
When these algorithms are applied to a set of stereo headsets, it fools your brain into believing that the sound is coming from several channels instead of two. The illusion created can be similar to that found in a 5.1 or 7.1 system.
But for this to work, testing has to be done on several individuals that are built differently and have different features such as different head shapes, pinna shapes, and size, and so on to create a generic algorithm that will be best suited for most virtual surround headphone users.
However, some algorithms can be altered to suit individuals which are done using photos of your head, shoulders, and ears to render individualized spatial sound but this is not commonly done. An example of a company that does this is Sony with its 360° Reality Audio software.
The reason virtual surround sound works so well on headphones is that they are very close to the ear where the sound is in a more controlled sound field with little interference such as crosstalk interference and you are not limited by your room’s layout or sitting position.
Examples of headphone virtual surround sound standards
1. Dolby Atmos surround for headphones
Dolby Atmos is a 3D object-based surround standard that can be used as a software solution that can be purchased for your gaming computer or console.
This standard is used with content that has been encoded in the Dolby Atmos format to create a virtual 3D surround sound experience with stereo headphones.
However, if the sound has not been mastered using this codec, it will create a 5.1 or 7.1 surround sound effect without the height element. This means that the experience will not be 3D since it does not up-mix content that has not been encoded in Dolby Atmos.
Dolby Atmos for headphones can be licensed for $15 but can also come as a free solution if you buy the Dolby headset bundle.
2. DTS Headphone:X
DTS Headphone:X is a Dolby Atmos alternative that is also an object-based surround sound standard for headphones.
This standard can be used with stereo headphones for an immersive experience but will only create a 3D bubble effect if the source has been encoded in DTS-X. If the content is not encoded in DTS, you will only have 5.1 or 7.1 surrounds depending on the content you are playing.
To get DTS-X for headphones, you will need to purchase the software which costs $20, or buy a DTS headset that will come bundled with the software.
3. Auro 3D for headphones
Auro 3D is an equivalent to Dolby Atmos and DTS-X and also comes with a virtual solution for headphones.
It also works best with Auro 3D content to create the illusion of sound coming all around you even from above but will also work with content that has not been encoded in Auro 3D for a 5.1 or 7.1 surround effect without the extra height element.
4. Windows Sonic for headphones
This is a free solution that can be accessed if you are using a Windows computer for gaming and watching movies.
Windows sonic will be supported by some games and content that have been encoded in surround sound formats.
To use Windows Sonic for headphones, right-click on the sound icon on your Windows Taskbar. You will see a Spatial Sound option which you can click on to see the Windows Sonic for Headphones option. Click on that option to turn on Windows Sonic and repeat the same process to turn it off.
5. Super X-FI Headphone Holography
This is a virtual surround sound option brought to you by Creative Labs.
Super X-Fi uses your face and ear profiles to personalize your surround sound experience when you are using your headphones. The photos are taken using an app on your smartphone or tablet.
It can be used as a software solution for stereo headset but can also come with Creative Lab’s virtual headphones that have an onboard DSP that processes your audio to give you an immersive surround sound experience.
6. 360° Reality Audio
This standard is similar to Super X-FI in that it personalizes your experience using your head and ear profiles but only works with Sony headphones.
It is also expensive since it is a monthly subscription service to me would not be ideal. This is not an option I would recommend for you.
7. THX Spatial Audio
THX is another software option that creates a virtual surround sound effect on stereo headphones and also comes with several presets that can be used to enhance your experience further depending on what you are watching or the game you are playing.
These are just some of the popular virtual surround sound option but there are others such as;
- Razer 7.1 Surround Sound
- Boom 3D by Global Delight
- Ultrasone S-Logic Headphone surrounds by Ultrasone.
- Dirac VR
- Yamaha Silent Cinema
I would also recommend getting a headphone DAC/Amp or soundcard that supports either Dolby or DTS surround sound solution and pair them with a great set of stereo headphones that do not have to be from either company.
Dolby and DTS are the two most widely used surround sound solutions and having a sound card or headphone amp that you can connect to either your gaming console, Blu-ray player, streaming box, or computer via a USB connection would be a great solution for many.
Some headphones DACs will also come with a wireless connection option that you can use with wireless headphones or current pair of earbuds such as Air Pods.
You do not have to buy virtual surround sound headphones to get a surround sound experience in your media room or gaming system.
True 5.1 or 7.1 surround sound headphones
True surround sound headphones use multiple small drivers that are strategically placed and angled to create a surround sound effect.
5.1 surround headphones have a total of 8 drivers, 4 drivers in each headphone cup. These drivers include a center channel driver, a from channel driver, a side surround driver, and a bass driver for each ear.
7.1 surround headphones boast a total of 10 drivers, 5 drivers for each ear. The drivers include all drivers found in a 5.1 headphone cup but with an extra rear surround channel for each ear.
There have to be two center-channel drivers since you cannot have a single center channel driver. The two center-channel drivers are combined to create a full center channel experience that is essential for dialogue and most speech in a movie or a game.
Most True surround headphones also come with a plug and play adapter where the decoding and equalization are done for a better and more immersive experience overall.
The downside to these headphones is that they tend to be bulky and expensive as it takes a lot of time and money to design, place the drivers, and make them work together perfectly.
The Low-Frequency Effect or LFE channel (the .1 channel)
This is something that most people tend to gloss over when talking about surround sound headphones.
The LFE channel is responsible for the bass effect but does not represent the number of bass drivers in a surround headphone. This is something that most people tend to get wrong.
So, how do surround headphones reproduce the low frequencies yet they do not have subwoofers required to move a lot of air which is crucial for adding depth to audio?
Low frequencies are felt more than they are heard but how can this effect be recreated in something as small and a pair of headphones? The answer lies in how close the headphones are to our ears, the headphone’s design, and our bone structure.
Since headphones are usually so close to our eardrums and ear bone structure, they do not need to move much air or rumble as much to produce bass and add to the depth effect.
Not much sound pressure is lost as would be with a subwoofer since the ears are literally on our ears.
These effects also hit our head bone and ear bone structures to vibrate them. The vibrations are then received by our brains which process the information to produce the same effect that a subwoofer would have on us.
How the surround headphones are designed also affects how we perceive the low-frequency effects. Most surround sound headphones have a sealed design with minimal leakage which when coupled with the proximity of the headphones to the ears create great bass and an immersive surround sound experience.
Surround sound headphones will not sound great if they do not have a great bass response. Depth is essential both in a surround sound system and a stereo system.
What to look for in surround sound headphones
- The most important thing to look for when buying surround headphones is audio quality. Sound quality is very subjective and if you can have the chance to listen to the headphones before buying, it would be ideal since you cannot judge how good headphones will sound by looking at them.
- Comfort is also essential, especially if you are a gamer or if you plan on binge-watching certain shows and movies using the headphones. This may vary depending on personal preference but you want a set that is light and has great cushions which are ideal for long use scenarios.
- Wider frequency response is also great. You want headphones that can at least play frequencies that are within the human hearing range which is 20Hz – 20kHz. You can go wider but for smoother ends.
- Some sort of noise-canceling technology will come in handy in keeping outside noise from affecting your concentration and listening. This can be either active noise canceling (ANC) or noise isolation
- Long battery life is important on surround headphones since most of the models need to be charged for use. At least 15 hours of battery life should be great since you may not be using your headset for longer than that in most cases.
- Headphones will collapsible ear cups are great since they are easier to store and tend to be more comfortable.
- You will also want headphones with some sort of built-in microphone and control module, especially if you love playing interactive PC and console games.
- Durability is also important but depends on how much you are willing to spend. Headphones will metallic and carbon fiber build will last longer but they also tend to be costlier.
Are surround sound headphones worth it?
Surround sound headphones are worth it, especially if you cannot afford to build a dedicated speaker surround system, if you do not have enough space, or if using a dedicated speaker system can interfere with other members of your family.
But many would argue that virtual surround headphones are better and will outperform true surround sound headphones which are also costlier. This is a sentiment I also share but this will also come down to personal preference as is a lot of things tech.
Being immersed in a game or a movie will improve your experience and will also determine if you perceive something as great.
High-quality sound is always better than a high-resolution image but if you can combine the two, you can take your movie watching, gaming, or music listening experience to the next level.